BRONICA S2A, S2, C - FLAT FILM PLANE AND SHARPNESS
by Sam Sherman [email protected]


Related Postings:
Film Flatness Issues

Related Articles by Sam Sherman:
Medium Format Film - Flatness or Not?
In Search of Crisp Images...
MF Film Flatness Issues
Bronica S2A Film Back Insert Variations
Bronica S2/A Film Back Variations
Bronica Focus Problem - And How to Solve It


Bronica 6x6cm Film Flatness Trick
Film flatness all across the format must be maintained to much less than the 0.005 inch tolerance*. To aid in this the Bronica has a spring-loaded bar which presses the film and pulls it taut. This bar is situated just outside the film aperture between two small guide rollers. It is actuated whenever the film drive is stopped. [*ordinary typing paper is 0.003-0.004"]
Source: p. 94, Modern Photography, April, p. 50, 90, 94; Inside Story, The 2 1/4 Single Lens Reflex, Bennett Sherman and Herbert Keppler

This is a followup to other writings I have done on this subject.

Old Bronica S2A cameras in excellent working condition, with good condition Nikkor optics and their finder foam replaced and aligned can take super-sharp photos rivalling expensive new Hasselblad and other medium format cameras.

One more item to check is the film inserts in the backs.

Obviously Bronica studied their film inserts which were the same for all "C" cameras plus "S2" and "S2A" with 12/24 exposure backs (120/220).

Closely examining these backs one can see major improvements made to them, although all versions interchange with the above cameras. Beware - they are not all the same.

Note:

1- The Early Version Inserts (type one) -Have Two rollers where the film rolls onto the takeup spool and the top and bottom rollers seem to be anodized black. The instructive test is usually in black letters on gold background.

2- Later Version Inserts (type two)- Have only One roller at the top where the film rolls onto the takeup spool and the top and bottom rollers are finished in Grey with a Teflon-like anti-stick coating. The instructive text is usually in silver or white letters on a black background. The letter "A" (not The Scarlet Letter) is sometimes embossed on the side of the insert indicating it to be a later model for S2A cameras- which will also work in C and S2.

3- There are in between variants of these two major types having some characteristics of both.

It is important to clean these inserts thoroughly and drop some light oil into all roller pivots.

My initial tests showed the Type Two inserts to produce a much flatter film plane for sharper images. Now, I have done a conclusive test.

Some years ago Modern Photography took some Hasselblad backs with film in them, removed the dark slides and projected grid patterns on the film in the apertures of the backs. All kinds of film bulging and rippling was noted, indicating these backs did not produce a flat film plane and at wide apertures unsharp images would result. That is why it was necessary with Hasselblad and other medium format cameras to stop the lenses down to allow for depth of field to cover up the unsharp images that these backs would cause..

MY TEST:

FIRST:

I took an S2A back and put in a Type One insert with a roll of film loaded. I closed the back (off the camera) and put a pen tip in the small silver button you see on the back faceplate which allowed me to remove the dark slide.

Next I turned the back's wind knob until I reached number one. It was hard to turn. The knob locked at number one so I had to insert a screwdriver into the slot on the back to release the wind knob and then turn to number two.

With this Type One insert - it was hard to turn the knob and I did this throughout the roll until I wound the film up. The film in the back's aperture was rippling badly and pressing a finger against it allowed me to push the film down against the pressure plate, indicating it was bulging badly - not a flat film plane.

Also important to note - these Type One inserts were hard to wind and must have contributed to wearing out the wind gears in S2 and C models.

SECOND:

I repeated this same test with a Type Two insert - this time it was smooth and easy to wind.

The film in the aperture did not bulge (to any great degree) and was lying flat against the pressure plate. The whole roll of film wound smoothly until it took up on the takeup spool.

CONCLUSION:

Owners of Bronica C, S2 and S2A cameras, examine all of your film inserts. If you have Type Two inserts - Good. If you have Type One inserts - do your best to get rid of them. Do as I have done, replace them with Type Two inserts - you will be very pleased with the improvements.